EPS 3894 — Stone Ridge: Insurance Proposal Comparison

Renewal: November 29, 2026 – November 29, 2027  |  9551 No. 3 Rd, Richmond, BC  |  14 units, 5 buildings, wood frame, built 2016

Prepared November 17, 2026  |  Analysis only — no binding recommendation

Now with a third column throughout: the current HUB policy 2025–26 ($14,379), from the Certificate of Insurance dated Dec 2, 2025 (policy BSP120251, Nov 29, 2025 – Nov 29, 2026). The HUB renewal quote for 2026–27 is still pending — this column is the policy in force now, not a new quote.

Headline verdict

Navacord is $848 cheaper on headline premium ($12,144 vs $12,992), but it is not a like-for-like comparison. BFL is materially broader on limits; Navacord is materially better on deductibles. Neither quote dominates the other.

BFL gives you substantially more cover where it matters in a catastrophe — 150% extended replacement cost vs 130%, $35M liability vs $10M, $25M D&O vs $5M, $2M employee dishonesty vs $50,000, $500,000 cyber liability vs $100,000 — and its earthquake and flood limits include the extended replacement cost, while Navacord's do not.

Navacord wins clearly on out-of-pocket cost at claim time: water and sewer backup deductibles of $10,000 vs BFL's $25,000, flood $25,000 vs $100,000, and earthquake 15% (min $100,000) vs 20% (min $250,000). On a $50,000 water claim Navacord pays $15,000 more; on a $150,000 flood claim it pays $75,000 more.

Equalising the two quotes destroys the price advantage either way. Bringing Navacord's CGL, D&O, crime, terrorism and cyber limits up toward BFL's adds $3,738 (total $15,882) — and still leaves it $5M short on liability, $5M short on D&O, and with no way in the proposal to buy the extra 20 points of replacement cost. Bringing BFL's flood and earthquake deductibles down to Navacord's levels adds $7,837 (total $20,829) — and there is no buy-down offered at all for the $25,000 water/sewer deductibles.

The real decision is frequency vs severity: Navacord is better for the common small-to-medium water/flood claim; BFL is better for a total loss or a large liability/D&O/crime event. Council should also note the proposals are summaries, not the full policy wordings — a definitive exclusion comparison is not possible from these two PDFs alone.

Against the current HUB policy ($14,379): Navacord is $2,235 cheaper but cuts the cover the strata already has — liability $30M → $10M, D&O $20M → $5M, employee dishonesty $1M → $50,000 — in exchange for much lower deductibles (water/sewer $10,000 vs $25,000, flood $25,000 vs $100,000, earthquake 15% vs 20%). BFL is $1,387 cheaper and is broadly at or above current cover — liability $35M vs $30M, D&O $25M vs $20M, crime $2M vs $1M, extended replacement 150% vs 130%, legal expense $2M/$5M vs $1M — with the same water ($25,000) and flood ($100,000) deductibles as now, except the earthquake minimum rises to $250,000 from $100,000. In other words, BFL is a cheaper version of roughly what the strata already has; Navacord is a cheaper, narrower package with better deductibles.

What we do not know about the current policy — and why it matters: the HUB certificate is a summary, not the wording. It states $50,000 additional living expense without saying total or per unit, lists only a $1,000,000 "limited" pollution aggregate with no per-event limit or deductible, and gives no exclusion list at all — the certificate itself says the policy documents prevail. So a silence on the certificate is unknown, not absent, and council should not assume the current cover is thinner or broader than the new quotes on those points until HUB's wording is checked. Full detail in §9.

At a glance

$12,144
Navacord premium (incl. $250 insurer fee)
$12,992
BFL premium
$14,379
Current — HUB 2025–26 (renewal quote still pending)

Navacord is $848 (6.5%) below BFL, $2,235 (15.5%) below last year. BFL is $1,387 (9.6%) below last year. Broker commission disclosed in both: Navacord $1,918 (15.8% of premium); BFL $2,608.14 (20.1% of premium). Commission is built into the premium in both cases.

ItemCurrent — HUB 2025–26NavacordBFLEdge
Property limit (stated amount, replacement cost, incl. by-laws)$7,600,000$7,636,000$7,636,000NEW $36,000 HIGHER
Extended replacement cost130% — $9,880,000 total130% — $9,926,800 total150% — $11,454,000 totalBFL +$1,527,200 vs Navacord; +$1,574,000 vs HUB
Earthquake limit$7,600,000 (property limit; no separate EQ cap stated)$7,636,000 (excl. ERC)$11,454,000 (incl. 150% ERC)BFL
Flood limit$7,600,000 (property limit; no separate flood cap stated)$7,636,000 (excl. ERC)$11,454,000 (incl. 150% ERC)BFL
General liability$30,000,000$10,000,000$35,000,000BFL 3.5× Navacord; Navacord is ⅓ of current
Directors & officers$20,000,000$5,000,000$25,000,000BFL 5× Navacord; Navacord is ¼ of current
Employee dishonesty (crime)$1,000,000$50,000$2,000,000BFL 40× Navacord; Navacord is 1/20 of current
Cyber liability / expense$50,000 (no liability/expense split stated)$100,000 / $50,000$500,000 / $250,000BFL 10× current
Pollution — each event / aggregateLimited $1,000,000 agg. under CGL; no separate pollution section stated$1,000,000 / $20,000,000 shared master$1,000,000 / $5,000,000 dedicatedBFL dedicated
Terrorism$500,000$500,000$1,000,000BFL 2×
Additional living expense$50,000 (total vs per unit not stated)*$5,000/unit; $50,000/occurrence*$50,000/unit; $1,000,000 aggregateBFL 10× Navacord*
Legal expense$1,000,000 agg.; $200,000 sub-limits$2,000,000 / $5,000,000 agg.$2,000,000 / $5,000,000 agg.BOTH NEW 2×/5× current
Water / sewer deductible$25,000 / $25,000$10,000 / $10,000$25,000 / $25,000NAVACORD (vs current too)
Flood deductible$100,000$25,000$100,000NAVACORD (vs current too)
Earthquake deductible20%, min $100,00015%, min $100,00020%, min $250,000NAVACORD; BFL min is worse than current

* Navacord's proposal table says $5,000/unit and $50,000/occurrence, but Angelina Lau's Nov 16 email says $50,000 per unit and a $1,000,000 aggregate — a 10× discrepancy. See "Discrepancies to confirm in writing" below. Do not rely on either figure until the broker confirms it. HUB's certificate simply states "$50,000" for additional living expense, with no per-unit / aggregate split stated — so it cannot be compared per-unit against either new quote without the HUB wording.

1. Premium and fees

Current — HUB 2025–26NavacordBFL
Total premium$14,379$12,144$12,992
Fees / retained premium shownNot stated on the certificate$250 insurer fee, fully earned; $1,843 minimum retained premiumNo fee breakdown in the proposal summary
Broker commission (disclosed, built into premium)Not stated on the certificate$1,918$2,608.14
Payment optionsNot stated on the certificateMonthly payment plan on request — 20% down, competitive ratesPremium financing available on request; must be in place at binding
Proposal validity / policy periodPolicy in force Nov 29, 2025 – Nov 29, 2026 (policy BSP120251)Effective 60 days or until effective date, whichever first; subject to change if claims become known before effective dateQuotation expires 30 days from Oct 29, 2026 — i.e. Nov 28, 2026, the day before renewal
Broker / contactHUB International Insurance Brokers, Abbotsford, (604) 425-3355Navacord Insurance Services West Inc. — Gordon Li, (604) 484-0117; Angelina LauBFL CANADA Risk and Insurance Services Inc. — Peggy Lee, (604) 678-5480
Underlying insurer(s) namedNamed in full on the certificate: Lloyd's syndicates led by Carbon 4747 (25%), QBE 2999 (20%), SCOR 2015 (15%), AXA XL 2003 (15%), IQUW 1856 (15%), Four Points (10%) for property; Aviva (boiler & machinery); BRIT 2987 for terrorism, crime, liability, cyber and D&O; Lloyd's Consortium 9773 for excess liability; Intact for excess D&O; HDI Global Specialty / ARAG for legal expense; Fortress for volunteer accident.Not named in the 11-page proposal (broker only). Legal expense: Technology Insurance Company Inc.Not named for the main program in the summary. Legal expense: Lloyd's Underwriters, led by SCOR Managing Agency Syndicate 2015, "A+" rated.

Neither new proposal names the underlying property/liability insurer in its summary pages — unlike the current HUB certificate, which names every insurer and participation share. Council should ask both brokers, in writing, who the insurer is and its financial rating before binding — the broker's name is not the insurer.

2. Property — limits and deductibles

Both new quotes: $7,636,000 all property, blanket by-laws, stated amount, replacement cost, appraisal dated Nov 29, 2026 (cycle 2, Normac Appraisals). Both waive co-insurance via the stated-amount basis. Business interruption / loss of profits (gross rentals): not covered in either. Current HUB: $7,600,000 on a Nov 29, 2025 appraisal, also stated amount with 130% ERC — so the new quotes raise the base limit by $36,000, and BFL raises the ERC total by $1,574,000 over current.

Peril / itemCurrent — HUB 2025–26Navacord — limit / deductibleBFL — limit / deductible
All risks (all other losses)$7,600,000 / $10,000$7,636,000 / $10,000$7,636,000 / $10,000
Extended replacement cost130% / $9,880,000 total130% / $9,926,800 total150% / $11,454,000 total
Earthquake (annual aggregate)$7,600,000 (property limit) / 20%, min $100,000 — ERC included, no EQ exclusion stated$7,636,000 / 15%, min $100,000 — ERC excluded$11,454,000 incl. ERC / 20%, min $250,000
Flood (annual aggregate)$7,600,000 (property limit) / $100,000$7,636,000 / $25,000 — ERC excluded$11,454,000 incl. ERC / $100,000
Water damage— / $25,000— / $10,000— / $25,000
Sewer backup— / $25,000— / $10,000— / $25,000
GlassBlanket glass endorsement / $250— / $250 (limit not stated)Blanket incl. lobby glass / $250 residential, $500 commercial, $1,000 canopy
Lock & key / master key$25,000 aggregate / $250 ded.$25,000 / $500 (email says $50,000 — see discrepancies)$25,000 / $2,500
Underground utilities extensionIncludedNot stated in the proposal summaryNot stated in the proposal summary
Excess property extensionsNot stated on the certificateNot listed as a separate sectionUp to $5,000,000 annually aggregated — excludes earthquake for this section only; main property extensions do include earthquake

What the deductibles mean in dollars

Claim scenarioCurrent HUB paysNavacord paysBFL paysDifference
$50,000 water damage claim$25,000$40,000$25,000Navacord +$15,000 vs both HUB and BFL
$50,000 sewer backup claim$25,000$40,000$25,000Navacord +$15,000 vs both HUB and BFL
$150,000 flood claim$50,000$125,000$50,000Navacord +$75,000 vs both HUB and BFL
Total earthquake loss ($7,600,000 under HUB; $7,636,000 under both new quotes)Deductible $1,520,000 (20% of $7,600,000)Deductible $1,145,400 (15%)Deductible $1,527,200 (20%)Navacord saves $374,600 vs HUB and $381,800 vs BFL out-of-pocket — but BFL's EQ limit is $3,818,000 higher than Navacord's because it includes ERC, and $3,854,000 higher than HUB's

Water damage is the largest source of strata claims. BFL's $25,000 water/sewer deductibles mean the strata self-insures the first $25,000 of every such claim — 2.5× Navacord's $10,000 — and there is no buy-down option listed for water/sewer in the BFL proposal.

Buy-down / buy-back options

3. Coverage-by-coverage comparison

CoverageCurrent — HUB 2025–26NavacordBFL
Equipment breakdownProperty limit ($7,600,000) / $1,000 ded. Insurer: Aviva Canada Inc. (100%). No sub-limits stated on the certificate.$7,636,000 / $1,000 ded. By-laws included. Sub-limits incl.: debris removal; $500k water damage; $500k ammonia; $500k hazardous substances; $500k professional fees; $100k contingent BI; $100k brands & labels; $100k fungus clean-up; $100k service interruption; $250k extra expense; $1,000,000 expediting expense. Loss of profits not covered.$7,636,000 / $1,000 ded. Standard comprehensive incl. production machines & electronic equipment. Deductible waived on losses over $25,000. Extra expense $1,000,000 (100% available in first month, 24-hr waiting). ALE $25,000/unit, $1,000,000 aggregate. Loss of profits not covered.
General liability$30,000,000 each occurrence (incl. $20M excess liability); products/completed ops agg. $30M; personal & advertising injury $30M; non-owned auto (SEF #6) $30M; medical payments $2,500/person, $25,000/occurrence; tenants' legal liability $500,000; employee benefit liability $1,000,000 agg.; $1,000 ded.$10,000,000 each occurrence; products/completed ops agg. $10M; non-owned auto $10M; advertising injury $10M; medical payments $50,000/person; tenants' legal liability $500,000 ($1,000 ded); voluntary compensation — strata volunteers $50,000 (weekly indemnity 2/3 wage, max $500/wk). $1,000 BI deductible waived on first BI loss if no prior BI loss in 5 years. No general aggregate. Property manager is additional named insured. Options: $15M +$295; $25M +$680; $30M +$1,065.$35,000,000 bodily injury & property damage; non-owned auto $35M; $1,000 ded. (no waiver stated). No medical payments, tenants' legal liability, voluntary compensation, advertising injury or products aggregate broken out in the summary — not stated, not necessarily absent.
Directors & officers (claims made)$20,000,000 (incl. $18M excess D&O; Intact for excess). Discrimination defence costs $25,000 annual aggregate.$5,000,000 annual agg.; defence costs outside the limit, uncapped; nil ded. Property manager professional liability extension included; discrimination defence costs and employment practices liability included. Highlights: $1M excess "Side A" dedicated council limit; contingent property manager extension; no "failure to maintain insurance" exclusion; no discrimination exclusion; entity coverage. Options: $10M +$224; $15M +$624; $20M +$861 (incl. PM errors & omissions).$25,000,000 claims made, incl. property manager; nil ded. Human rights defence costs incl. punitive/exemplary damages included. Privacy event expenses and cyber liability marked "not applicable" under D&O (covered under the separate cyber section).
CrimeEmployee dishonesty Form A $1,000,000; broad form money & securities $10,000; forgery & alteration / money orders / counterfeit / credit card forgery $10,000; social engineering fraud $5,000.Employee dishonesty Form A $50,000, nil ded.; property manager & designated persons $50,000; broad form money & securities $25,000. Options to $100k +$130; $250k +$380; $500k +$600; $1M +$1,055; $2M +$1,630.Employee dishonesty incl. property manager & elected officer theft $2,000,000, nil ded.; broad form money & securities $10,000, nil ded.
Pollution liabilityLimited pollution liability $1,000,000 aggregate under the CGL section. No separate pollution section, no per-event limit and no deductible stated on the certificate.$1,000,000 each event (BI/PD + clean-up), $10,000 ded.; aggregate (master) $20,000,000 — shared by all certificate holders under the master policy (see application footnote).$1,000,000 each event, $25,000 ded.; aggregate $5,000,000 — cover letter states these limits are no longer shared and are dedicated to this insured location.
Terrorism & sabotage$500,000 / $1,000 ded. Insurer: Lloyd's led by BRIT Syndicate 2987 (100%).$500,000 / $2,500 ded. Options: $1M +$82; $2M +$110.$1,000,000 per occurrence and annual agg. / $1,000 ded. Options: $2M +$63; $5M +$213.
Group / volunteer accidentPrincipal sum $250,000; $500 deductible (per certificate). Insurer: Fortress Insurance Company (100%). No weekly indemnity / dental breakdown stated.Principal sum $150,000; weekly indemnity $500 (max 52 wks); excess principal sum $350,000; accident expenses up to $15,000; dental $5,000; 7-day waiting period. Options: $250k +$23 (excess $750k); $350k +$52 (excess $1,650,000).Volunteer accident — maximum limit of loss $2,000,000 ("see policy wordings"). No breakdown of principal sum, weekly indemnity, dental or waiting period in the proposal summary.
Cyber / privacy & data breach$50,000 / $500 ded. No liability/expense split stated on the certificate. Insurer: Lloyd's led by BRIT Syndicate 2987.Intellect Privacy & Data Breach: liability $100,000; expense $50,000; $5,000 ded. Option: $250,000 +$100. Email lists $50k privacy breach expense, $100k liability, $50k cyber extortion, $25k social engineering, $25k crisis management — extortion/social engineering are not in the proposal table.BFL Realty Cyber Program (enhanced wording): certificate limit $500,000. Liability (security, privacy, regulatory) $500,000, $5,000 ded.; first party (breach costs, cyber extortion, digital asset replacement) $250,000, $5,000 ded.; social engineering funds transfer / funds held in trust $50,000, $5,000 ded. Aggregate policy limit $60,000,000 across all subscribers.
Legal expense$1,000,000 aggregate per annual period; $200,000 sub-limits each for legal defence, contract disputes & debt recovery, property protection, bodily injury, and strata council/owner disputes. Insurer: HDI Global Specialty / ARAG Legal Solutions.$2,000,000 any one claim; $5,000,000 annual agg.; nil ded. Underwriter: Technology Insurance Company Inc. Clark Wilson legal services retainer not in base price — Platinum option $500 (fully earned): $1,000,000 per claim / $1,500,000 aggregate, unlimited advice on Strata Property Act matters if purchased.$2,000,000 any one claim; $5,000,000 annual agg.; nil ded. Endorsement A or B applies per policy wording. Includes BFL enhanced legal expense & assistance with digital legal platform; underwritten by Lloyd's, led by SCOR Syndicate 2015 ("A+"); property manager coverage included up to full policy limit. Clark Wilson not named.
Additional living expense$50,000 — total vs per unit not stated on the certificate, so it cannot be compared per-unit against either new quote.$5,000/unit; $50,000/occurrence per proposal table — conflicts with the Nov 16 email ($50,000/unit; $1,000,000 agg.). See discrepancies.$50,000/unit; $1,000,000 annual aggregate. (Marketing pages mention "an additional $5M" for ALE — not reconciled to the $1M table figure; ask BFL.)
Business interruptionNot stated on the certificate — do not read this as covered or excluded.Not covered (both new quotes)Not covered (both new quotes)

4. The equalisation test — what "same cover" would actually cost

Bringing Navacord up toward BFL's headline limits (using Navacord's own listed options):

A partial equalisation (CGL $15M +$295, D&O $10M +$224, Crime $500k +$600, Terrorism $1M +$82, Cyber $250k +$100 = +$1,301 → $13,445) already costs $453 more than BFL while still leaving D&O $15M short, crime $1.5M short and ERC $1.53M short.

Bringing BFL's deductibles down to Navacord's levels: flood to $25,000 +$3,973 and earthquake to 15% +$3,864 = +$7,837 → $20,829, and water/sewer would still sit at $25,000 because no buy-down is offered for them.

Conclusion: the $848 headline saving is real only if council accepts Navacord's lower limits and its (much better) deductibles as the package. Once you price the limit gap, Navacord is the more expensive quote.

5. Exclusions and policy wordings — what can actually be compared

Important limit on this whole comparison: both PDFs are proposal summaries, not the full policy wordings. Neither contains a complete exclusion list. The differences below are only the exclusions and conditions each broker chose to flag. A definitive wording comparison requires the specimen wordings from both brokers.

Stated in the Navacord proposal only

Stated in the BFL proposal only

Stated in both

MATERIAL GAP TO VERIFY  BFL's asbestos + mould/mildew/fungus clause and its CGL total pollution exclusion are the only exclusions visible in one proposal and not the other. Before binding BFL, council should ask what the mould clause actually excludes — mould after a water leak is a common strata claim scenario — and whether the CGL pollution exclusion leaves any gap for, say, an oil-tank or heating-fuel leak that is not a "pollution event" under the separate pollution section.

6. Binding conditions / subjectivities

ConditionCurrent — HUB 2025–26NavacordBFL
No flood warnings / wildfire / flooding within 50 km at bindingNot stated on the certificate (binding conditions are not shown on a certificate of insurance)Yes — no flood warnings within 50 kmYes — no active wildfires or flooding within 50 km
No known / unreported lossesNot stated on the certificateYesYes, plus no material changes before effective date
Signed applicationsNot stated on the certificateUnderwriting application (signed); pollution liability application (completed & signed); D&O application (completed & signed by a council member)D&O questionnaire (claims in last 5 years?); cyber statement certified "NO" (no matter likely to give rise to a loss/claim in last 5 years); pollution exposures question (underground/above-ground propane, oil or septic tanks?)
Other paperworkNot stated on the certificate—CASL + privacy consent forms to sign and return; premium financing contract if used (must be in place at binding)
Snow removalNot stated on the certificateNot a condition in the proposalThird-party snow removal contract required; detailed log if obligation not met
OtherCertificate states it is "subject to all the limitations, exclusions and conditions" of the policies, and that the policy documents prevail over the certificate if there is a discrepancyProposal subject to change if claims become known before effective dateAsbestos exclusion + mould/mildew/fungus clause apply; CGL communicable-disease and total-pollution exclusions apply

7. Discrepancies to confirm in writing before any decision

New — HUB certificate silences. The certificate is a summary, not the wording: it does not state the HUB additional living expense basis ($50,000 — total or per unit?), the pollution per-event limit or deductible (only a $1,000,000 aggregate under CGL), any exclusion list, or the binding conditions. Do not treat a silence on the certificate as proof that a cover or exclusion is absent — the certificate itself says the policy documents prevail.

  1. Navacord additional living expense — 10× discrepancy. Proposal table: $5,000/unit, $50,000/occurrence. Angelina Lau's Nov 16 email: $50,000 per unit, $1,000,000 aggregate. If the table is right, BFL's ALE is 10× Navacord's; if the email is right, they are identical. Ask Navacord to confirm in writing.
  2. Navacord locks & keys — $25,000 vs $50,000. Proposal table: $25,000 master key limit. Email: $50,000 replacement of locks and keys per occurrence. Same ask.
  3. Navacord pollution aggregate — shared, unknown participants. $20,000,000 is a master-policy aggregate shared by all certificate holders. Ask Navacord how many strata share it, what the aggregate usage has been, and whether EPS 3894's $1,000,000 per-event limit is genuinely available in full if another certificate holder has a large pollution claim first.
  4. Underlying insurers — unnamed in both proposals. Ask both brokers for the insurer name(s) and AM Best / rating for each section, in writing.
  5. BFL marketing vs table — ALE "$5M". BFL's marketing pages say "an additional $5M" for additional living expenses; the insuring-agreement table says $1,000,000 aggregate. Ask which is correct, and whether the $5M refers to the excess property extensions (which exclude earthquake).
  6. BFL volunteer accident — $2,000,000 with no breakdown. Navacord gives principal sum, weekly indemnity, dental and waiting period; BFL gives only a headline limit and "see policy wordings". Ask BFL for the breakdown before comparing this section.
  7. BFL cyber — $60,000,000 aggregate is shared across all subscribers; the operative limit for EPS 3894 is the $500,000 certificate limit. Confirm that understanding.
  8. BFL quote expiry — Nov 28, 2026. The BFL quotation expires 30 days from Oct 29, the day before renewal. If council wants BFL, confirm the quote is still holdable / re-issuable and on what terms.
  9. Navacord D&O — "other than Intact" reference. The D&O application says if currently insured by an insurer other than Intact, report known circumstances to that insurer. This hints the underlying D&O insurer may be Intact — ask Navacord to confirm; do not assume it.

8. Open questions for the brokers / council

  1. Ask both brokers for the specimen policy wordings (property, CGL, D&O, pollution, cyber) and a side-by-side exclusion schedule — the two proposal summaries cannot settle the wording question Franky asked about.
  2. Are $10M CGL and $5M D&O adequate for a 14-unit strata, or does council want the $35M / $25M headroom BFL builds in? What do the strata's bylaws / the Strata Property Act require as a minimum?
  3. Is $50,000 employee dishonesty adequate given the strata's operating and contingency reserve fund balances, or is BFL's $2,000,000 the right level? (This alone is a $1,630 option on Navacord.)
  4. What is the strata's claims history for water/flood? If water claims are frequent, Navacord's $10,000 deductible saves $15,000 per $50,000 claim vs BFL — that can erase the $848 premium saving in a single claim, in BFL's favour in reverse: one water claim under BFL costs the strata $15,000 more out of pocket.
  5. Does the strata hold a third-party snow removal contract that satisfies BFL's condition (TK&B engaged Nov 9 — confirm the contract is in place and the log is being kept)?
  6. Wait for the HUB renewal quote for 2026–27 (current insurer; $14,379 for 2025–26) before deciding, as Loretta proposed — or decide now between these two and treat HUB as a check? The HUB column in this comparison is the 2025–26 policy in force, not a renewal quote, so it cannot be used as a like-for-like price for next year.
  7. Confirm the earthquake / flood ERC treatment in writing with Navacord: is the $7,636,000 EQ/flood cap really exclusive of the 130% ERC, i.e. is the most the strata can recover for a total earthquake loss $7,636,000 under Navacord vs $11,454,000 under BFL?

9. Current policy — HUB 2025–26, in full (from the certificate)

Policy BSP120251, Nov 29, 2025 – Nov 29, 2026, HUB International Insurance Brokers. Named insured: the Owners of Strata Plan EPS 3894 o/a Stone Ridge, 9551 No. 3 Road, Richmond — 14 residential suites in 5 buildings. Premium $14,379 (Yoyo Chiu, Nov 25, 2025 — HUB was chosen that year over Acera $16,893 and BFL $18,954; last year, with BFL, the premium had been about $23,371).

What the current policy gives the strata today: property $7,600,000 with 130% ERC ($9,880,000 total), water/sewer $25,000, flood $100,000, earthquake 20% / $100,000 minimum, glass $250, keys/locks $25,000 aggregate, ALE $50,000 (basis not stated), liability $30,000,000, D&O $20,000,000, crime $1,000,000, equipment breakdown at the property limit, volunteer accident $250,000, legal expense $1,000,000 aggregate ($200,000 sub-limits), terrorism $500,000, cyber $50,000.

Insurers (named on the certificate — neither new proposal does this): property — Lloyd's led by Carbon Syndicate 4747 (25%), QBE 2999 (20%), SCOR 2015 (15%), AXA XL 2003 (15%), IQUW 1856 (15%), Four Points (10%); boiler & machinery — Aviva Canada (100%); terrorism, crime, liability, cyber, D&O — Lloyd's led by BRIT Syndicate 2987 (100%); excess liability — Lloyd's Consortium 9773 led by AEGIS; excess D&O — Intact; legal expense — HDI Global Specialty / ARAG; volunteer accident — Fortress.

Where the certificate is silent — read these as "unknown", not "absent": ALE basis ($50,000 total vs per unit); pollution per-event limit and deductible (only the $1,000,000 aggregate under CGL is stated, described as "limited"); any exclusion list (the certificate says it is subject to all limitations, exclusions and conditions of the policies, and the policy documents prevail over the certificate); business interruption; binding conditions; fees and commission.

Sharpest vs-current takeaways: (1) Navacord's $2,235 saving comes with liability, D&O and crime limits at one-third, one-quarter and one-twentieth of current — the strata would be less covered than it is today on the three sections that protect council and the reserve fund. (2) BFL's $1,387 saving comes with limits at or above current on every headline section, and legal expense at double the current aggregate. (3) The only place either new quote is unambiguously better than current on deductibles is Navacord (water/sewer, flood, earthquake); BFL matches current on water and flood and is worse on the earthquake minimum ($250,000 vs $100,000). (4) Both new quotes more than double current cyber cover ($50,000 → $100,000 Navacord / $500,000 BFL) and double legal expense — the two sections where current cover is thinnest.

Sources

Navacord proposal PDF — "Residential Strata Program – Insurance Proposal", Gordon Li, Nov 16, 2026, 11 pages; plus Angelina Lau's Nov 16, 2026 email forwarded by Loretta Mok (lorettamok@citybase.ca). BFL proposal PDF — "Strata Protect Insurance Proposal", Peggy Lee, Oct 29, 2026, 20 pages; plus Loretta Mok's Nov 13, 2026 email. Current HUB: Certificate of Insurance, HUB International Insurance Brokers, dated Dec 2, 2025, policy BSP120251, Nov 29, 2025 – Nov 29, 2026 (2 pp, plus the Dec 3, 2025 Citybase notice posting the 2025–2026 Insurance Summary of Coverages); premium $14,379 per Yoyo Chiu's Nov 25, 2025 email (Gmail 19abda5623b78aab), which also records Acera $16,893 and BFL $18,954 that year. HUB renewal proposal for 2026–27 still pending at time of writing. All figures are as stated in those documents; where the email and the proposal table conflict, both figures are shown and flagged. This is an analysis of proposal summaries and a certificate only — it is not the full policy wording and is not a binding recommendation.